Find the Stolen Number

A number thief has hidden one card. Count along the number line to discover which one is missing.

  • 2½ years
  • Quick prep
  • At home
  • About 15 minutes
Focus
Download printable activity (PDF)Opens in a new tab
  1. 1

    Arrange the number cards from a deck in order and choose a toy to be the Number Thief.

  2. 2

    Demonstrate once: hide one card, count forward from 1, and stop where the sequence has a gap.

  3. 3

    Ask your child to close their eyes while the toy steals one card, then ask which number is missing.

  4. 4

    Let your child search first. After a pause, remind them that counting the row one card at a time can help.

  5. 5

    If they become stuck, count together and stop before the gap: “One, two…what comes next?”

  6. 6

    When the number is found, make the toy say, “You caught me! It was 3.” Let your child return the card and choose whether to play again.

  • Counts the playing cards one by one and finds the missing numbers Emergent Mathematical Thinking
  • Reads the numbers on several playing cards Emergent Literacy
  • Start with the numerals from 1 to 5. When your child can find the missing numeral easily, try a longer sequence or remove more than one card.
  • Cognitive: Counting through a row to find a missing numeral helps your child become familiar with number order and use the sequence as a clue.
  • Language: Repeatedly seeing, hearing, and saying number names helps your child connect each written numeral with its pronunciation.

Better Parenting Content Team · Updated September 11, 2026